Black Cat Bone

Doktor Rokster wrote:A.

soul-a-skope wrote:on a one to one basis, i like list A better. however, there's something a bit more honest about list B, and it intrigues me more, if that makes sense?

B

Eric Soundtracks wrote:A.

moonie wrote:I like both- the Fall track really decided this one for me, so I'll go with


(drum roll please)

A

Corporal Moddie! wrote:A's list seems to be covering bases, but that's not a bad thing necessarilly -I think it would be unfair if it gets accused of being a contrived list. Most of it works well for me (don't know the Cave track) and The Stone Roses selection is a brave, and good, one. B's list will probably be popular on here, but isn't my thing.
Easy win for A.

Walk In My Shadow wrote:A

Baron XVII wrote:I can't muster the enthusiasm to vote for either one.

jimjim wrote:A by a country mile.

kaspar wrote:A

Matty Red Sox wrote:A even with the Cohen. and I liked the Stone Roses choice.

Owen wrote:a's choices are obvious but mainly because they are undoubted good songs. I read the list and thought Nice but.... then scrolled down and saw B and found it underwhelming.

A but i'm not sure i would have voted for it against much else.

Lord Belborough wrote:A

Sambient wrote:Meanwhile, I think A is the best list posted yet.

Giraffe wrote:my revolutionary new scoring system gives it to A by a hair (but i only knew two songs from B).

Velvis wrote:A.

Kudos for Messiah Ward. Great song.

Corporate Whore wrote:A A bit too 'obvious', but on the other hand, its a decent collection of songs. This one won't go the distance either.

The Fish wrote:A

Diamond Dog wrote:B is an elitist twat, so it's no surprise that my vote goes to the best list so far : A

Morning Star wrote:A has it's mistakes (WRONG Dusty song for a start!) but I like it a lot otherwise. I'm not so familiar with B's choices and what I do know isn't my cup of tea.

And I love Jeepster.

A

John_K wrote:Despite B featuring 'Thirteen'

A